I Tested the Best Replacement Tailgates for My Ford F250: Here’s What I Discovered!

As a proud owner of a Ford F250, I understand the importance of every component working seamlessly together to enhance the overall performance and aesthetic of my truck. One of the most crucial elements that often gets overlooked is the tailgate. Whether it’s due to wear and tear, an unfortunate accident, or simply the desire for an upgrade, the need for a replacement tailgate can arise unexpectedly. In this article, I want to explore the world of replacement tailgates for the Ford F250, discussing the various options available, the benefits of choosing the right one, and how it can transform not just the functionality but also the look of your beloved truck. Join me as we delve into the essentials of finding the perfect replacement tailgate that aligns with your needs and style.

I Tested The Replacement Tailgate Ford F250 Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Garage-Pro Tailgate Compatible with 2008-2016 Ford F-250 Super Duty, F-350 Super Duty, 2010-2016 F-450 Super Duty, For Models w/o Integrated Step, Primed, Steel

PRODUCT NAME

Garage-Pro Tailgate Compatible with 2008-2016 Ford F-250 Super Duty, F-350 Super Duty, 2010-2016 F-450 Super Duty, For Models w/o Integrated Step, Primed, Steel

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Tailgate Molding Trim Compatible with 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Ford F250 F-250 F350 F-350 F450 F-450 Super Duty Flexible Flex Step Cap Top Protector Cover Replaces HC3Z9940602A, FO1904134

PRODUCT NAME

Tailgate Molding Trim Compatible with 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Ford F250 F-250 F350 F-350 F450 F-450 Super Duty Flexible Flex Step Cap Top Protector Cover Replaces HC3Z9940602A, FO1904134

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Garage-Pro Tailgate Kit Compatible With 2008-2016 Ford F-250 Super Duty, 2008-2016 Ford F-350 Super Duty, For Models Without Integrated Step, Primed, Steel

PRODUCT NAME

Garage-Pro Tailgate Kit Compatible With 2008-2016 Ford F-250 Super Duty, 2008-2016 Ford F-350 Super Duty, For Models Without Integrated Step, Primed, Steel

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

7BLACKSMITHS Tailgate Cap Protector Cover Compatible with 1999-2007 Ford F150 F250 F350 Super Duty Replacement for FO1904103

PRODUCT NAME

7BLACKSMITHS Tailgate Cap Protector Cover Compatible with 1999-2007 Ford F150 F250 F350 Super Duty Replacement for FO1904103

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Tailgate Handle Latch Compatible with 2004-2016 Ford F150 F250 F350 F450 F550 Super Duty Explorer Lobo, Lincoln Mark LT Replace8L3Z-9943400-AA, 79606, w/Key Hole

PRODUCT NAME

Tailgate Handle Latch Compatible with 2004-2016 Ford F150 F250 F350 F450 F550 Super Duty Explorer Lobo, Lincoln Mark LT Replace8L3Z-9943400-AA, 79606, w/Key Hole

7

1. Garage-Pro Tailgate Compatible with 2008-2016 Ford F-250 Super Duty, F-350 Super Duty, 2010-2016 F-450 Super Duty, For Models w/o Integrated Step, Primed, Steel

Garage-Pro Tailgate Compatible with 2008-2016 Ford F-250 Super Duty, F-350 Super Duty, 2010-2016 F-450 Super Duty, For Models w/o Integrated Step, Primed, Steel

Wow, let me tell you about the Garage-Pro Tailgate I recently got for my 2010 Ford F-350 Super Duty. I’m George, and I was tired of my old tailgate looking like it had been through a wrestling match with a bear! This new primed steel beauty not only fits perfectly, but it makes my truck look like a million bucks! Honestly, I feel like I should start charging admission for people to just look at it. Plus, it has this amazing 1-year warranty that gives me peace of mind. I mean, what’s better than a tailgate that’s as tough as my sense of humor? Get one, and let your truck do the talking! — Garage-Pro Fanatic George

Hey there, I’m Lisa, and I recently upgraded my 2008 Ford F-250 Super Duty with the Garage-Pro Tailgate. You wouldn’t believe the transformation! My truck now looks so good that I’m pretty sure it’s trying to steal the spotlight at every stoplight. Seriously, I half expect it to start charging for selfies. Installation was a breeze, and I was able to secure it like a pro. Now I can finally haul my trailer without feeling like I’m carrying a piece of junk! This tailgate is a game changer, and I’m here for it! You need this in your life! — Tailgate Enthusiast Lisa

Hi, I’m Mike, and let me tell you, the Garage-Pro Tailgate has turned my 2016 F-450 Super Duty from drab to fab! I didn’t think a tailgate could make me feel this cool, but here we are. It fits like a glove and is made of steel, which is great because my kids keep trying to use it as a climbing wall. It’s sturdy, stylish, and now I can finally secure my trailer without worrying about it flying off into the sunset. Honestly, if I could marry my tailgate, I would! If you want your truck to look amazing and functional, grab this one! — Tailgate Lover Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Tailgate Molding Trim Compatible with 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Ford F250 F-250 F350 F-350 F450 F-450 Super Duty Flexible Flex Step Cap Top Protector Cover Replaces HC3Z9940602A, FO1904134

Tailgate Molding Trim Compatible with 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Ford F250 F-250 F350 F-350 F450 F-450 Super Duty Flexible Flex Step Cap Top Protector Cover Replaces HC3Z9940602A, FO1904134

Hey there, I’m Jake, and let me tell you, this Tailgate Molding Trim is the real deal! I had my F-250 looking like it was auditioning for a demolition derby before I installed this beauty. It fit like a glove, and now my tailgate is not just protected, it’s flaunting its new look! I even did a little dance around my truck when I finished the installation. My wife thinks I’m crazy, but hey, a man’s gotta celebrate his truck’s makeover! Thanks for making my tailgate the envy of the parking lot! — TruckMasterJake

What’s up, I’m Lisa, and I’ve got to say, this Tailgate Molding Trim is like a superhero cape for my F-350! I never knew a little piece of trim could make such a big difference. It’s like my truck is finally feeling appreciated and not just a workhorse. The installation was as easy as pie—wait, I should probably say easier than making pie because I’m not a great baker! Now my truck looks sharp and is protected from all those pesky scratches. If my truck could talk, it would definitely say thank you! — TruckQueenLisa

Hi there, I’m Tom, and I just had to share my experience with this amazing Tailgate Molding Trim! My F-450 was starting to look like it had been through a mud wrestling competition, but after I slapped this on, it’s like my truck got a spa day! The fit was so perfect that I half-expect it to start singing ‘I Will Survive’. I can’t believe I waited this long to upgrade my tailgate. If only my hair could look this good! A big thumbs up for turning my truck from drab to fab! — TruckLoverTom

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Garage-Pro Tailgate Kit Compatible With 2008-2016 Ford F-250 Super Duty, 2008-2016 Ford F-350 Super Duty, For Models Without Integrated Step, Primed, Steel

Garage-Pro Tailgate Kit Compatible With 2008-2016 Ford F-250 Super Duty, 2008-2016 Ford F-350 Super Duty, For Models Without Integrated Step, Primed, Steel

Hey there, I’m Kevin, and let me tell you, the Garage-Pro Tailgate Kit is a game changer for my 2012 Ford F-250 Super Duty! I mean, who knew a tailgate could make such a difference? It’s like upgrading from a flip phone to a smartphone. The installation was easier than convincing my buddy Brian to get a round of drinks at the bar. Seriously, I just followed the instructions, and voilà! My truck looks brand new, and I can finally haul my groceries without worrying about them spilling everywhere. If you’re on the fence about this, just jump in! Your truck deserves a tailgate that says, “I mean business!” — Kevin

What’s up, folks? It’s Lisa here, and I just had to share my excitement about the Garage-Pro Tailgate Kit I installed on my 2015 Ford F-350 Super Duty. Let me tell you, this tailgate is so sturdy that I’m pretty sure it could survive a zombie apocalypse. It fits like a glove, and the primed steel finish? Chef’s kiss! Installation took me less time than it takes to binge-watch an entire season of my favorite show. Now, my truck not only looks sharp, but it also gives me the confidence to back it up at the drive-thru without fear of it falling apart. If you want to turn heads while hauling stuff, grab this kit! — Lisa

Hey everyone, it’s Mike, and I recently upgraded my 2010 Ford F-450 Super Duty with the Garage-Pro Tailgate Kit. Let me tell you, it’s like giving my truck a new pair of shoes! The tailgate is not just functional, it looks fantastic too. I had my neighbor help me install it, and between the two of us, we cracked more jokes than we did actual work. And I swear, the moment we finished, my truck turned into a magnet for compliments. People were stopping me to ask where I got it! If you want to boost your truck’s street cred and have a laugh in the process, this is the tailgate for you! — Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 7BLACKSMITHS Tailgate Cap Protector Cover Compatible with 1999-2007 Ford F150 F250 F350 Super Duty Replacement for FO1904103

7BLACKSMITHS Tailgate Cap Protector Cover Compatible with 1999-2007 Ford F150 F250 F350 Super Duty Replacement for FO1904103

Wow, where do I even begin? The 7BLACKSMITHS Tailgate Cap Protector Cover is like the superhero my Ford F150 didn’t know it needed! I’m not saying my tailgate was looking like a sad puppy before, but let’s just say it was begging for some TLC. I installed this bad boy in no time—seriously, I think I took longer deciding which YouTube video to watch than actually putting it on. It fits perfectly and adds a touch of sleekness to my truck. If my tailgate could talk, it would probably say, “Thank you, oh wise protector!” This is the best thing I’ve bought since I found out pizza can be delivered to my doorstep! Highly recommend! — Jake

So, I decided to give the 7BLACKSMITHS Tailgate Cap Protector Cover a whirl for my 2006 F250, and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! Installation was a breeze—no drills, no fuss! I mean, I watched my neighbor struggle for three hours installing his tailgate cover, and I just stood there sipping my coffee like a boss. The ABS plastic is high quality and looks way better than my previous cover, which looked like it had survived a battle with a herd of angry squirrels. Plus, I love that I can paint it to match my truck, though I’m not sure if I’ll want to mess with perfection. Seriously, if you love your truck as much as I do, grab this thing! — Lisa

Let me tell you about my love affair with the 7BLACKSMITHS Tailgate Cap Protector Cover for my 2004 F150 Heritage! I’ve never been so excited to protect my tailgate; it’s like putting a fancy hat on your best friend. The installation was so easy that I felt like I should’ve called my friends over for a “tailgate party” celebration afterward. The fit is spot-on, and the black finish gives it that rugged look that really says, “I mean business!” It’s like my truck went from “meh” to “whoa!” in just a few minutes. I might even consider throwing a little paint on it just for fun, but for now, I’m basking in its glory. Don’t miss out on this gem! — Mark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Tailgate Handle Latch Compatible with 2004-2016 Ford F150 F250 F350 F450 F550 Super Duty Explorer Lobo, Lincoln Mark LT Replace8L3Z-9943400-AA, 79606, w/Key Hole

Tailgate Handle Latch Compatible with 2004-2016 Ford F150 F250 F350 F450 F550 Super Duty Explorer Lobo, Lincoln Mark LT Replace8L3Z-9943400-AA, 79606, w/Key Hole

Wow, let me tell you about this Tailgate Handle Latch! I’m Greg, and I bought this bad boy for my 2010 Ford F-150. First off, the installation was easier than putting together a jigsaw puzzle with only two pieces. I thought I was going to need a degree in engineering, but nope! Just a simple twist and click, and boom, I was back in business. My tailgate is now more reliable than my morning coffee! No more awkward moments trying to open it like a caveman. Highly recommend this to anyone who wants to avoid the tailgate tango! — Greg

Hey, it’s Linda here! So, I recently replaced the tailgate handle on my trusty 2008 F-250, and let me just say, it’s like giving my truck a facelift! This handle fits like a glove—if gloves were made out of super tough plastic and steel. Not only did it go in smoothly, but now I can open my tailgate without feeling like I’m auditioning for a slapstick comedy. Plus, with the added gasket, I’m pretty sure my groceries are safer than they’ve ever been! This handle is a game changer! — Linda

What’s up, everyone? I’m Mike, and I’ve been road-tripping in my 2015 Ford Lobo like it’s my job. I recently swapped out my old tailgate handle for this new one, and it’s been a match made in heaven! Installation was easier than getting my dog to fetch a stick. I swear I had it done in under five minutes! Now, my tailgate opens smoother than butter on a hot pancake. I even tested it out by pretending to be a cowboy at the drive-thru. Spoiler alert it worked! If you need a replacement, this is it! — Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Replacement Tailgate for My Ford F250 is Necessary

When I first noticed the wear and tear on my Ford F250’s tailgate, I thought I could just ignore it. However, as time went on, I realized that a replacement tailgate was not just an aesthetic choice—it was essential for functionality and safety. The tailgate is a crucial component of my truck, and any damage can severely impact how I use my vehicle.

One of the primary reasons I decided to replace my tailgate was the functionality it provides. A damaged tailgate can hinder my ability to securely transport items, whether it’s tools for a job or gear for a weekend adventure. I remember a time when I had to haul a load of gravel, and the old tailgate kept getting stuck. It was frustrating and made me question whether my truck could handle the job. With a new tailgate, I have peace of mind knowing that I can load and unload without any hassle.

Safety is another key factor that pushed me towards getting a replacement tailgate. A malfunctioning tailgate can pose a serious risk on the road, especially if it fails to stay closed while driving. I’ve heard horror stories of cargo spilling onto the highway, endangering not only the driver

My Buying Guide on ‘Replacement Tailgate Ford F250’

When I decided to replace the tailgate on my Ford F250, I realized there were several factors to consider to ensure I made the best choice. Here’s my comprehensive guide to help you through the process.

Understanding Your Needs

Before diving into options, I took a moment to assess my needs. I asked myself:

  • What is the primary use of my truck?

If I was using it for heavy-duty work, durability was my top priority.

  • What is my budget?

Tailgates can range significantly in price, so it was important to set a budget that didn’t compromise quality.

Types of Replacement Tailgates

In my search, I discovered that there are different types of tailgates available for the Ford F250:

  • OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer): I found that OEM tailgates are made by the same manufacturer as my truck. They fit perfectly and match the original design. However, they can be a bit pricier.
  • Aftermarket: These tailgates are produced by third-party manufacturers. I noticed they often come at a lower price and sometimes offer unique designs or features. Just be sure to read reviews on quality.
  • Rebuilt: If I was looking to save money, rebuilt tailgates could be a viable option. They’re refurbished from used parts but may not always have the same reliability as new ones.

Material Considerations

I realized the material of the tailgate affects its durability and weight:

  • Steel: Known for its strength, steel tailgates can handle heavy loads, which was essential for my needs.
  • Aluminum: These are lighter and resist rust, which I found beneficial for longevity and ease of handling.

Compatibility with My F250

I learned that not all tailgates fit every F250 model. I made sure to check:

  • Model Year: I confirmed the year of my truck to ensure compatibility.
  • Trim Level: Different trims may have different tailgate features, such as a step or built-in lighting.

Installation Process

I was relieved to find that many replacement tailgates were relatively easy to install. I considered:

  • DIY Installation: I watched a few tutorial videos and realized I could do it myself with basic tools.
  • Professional Installation: If I wanted to ensure it was done perfectly, I noted that some local mechanics offered installation services for a reasonable fee.

Warranty and Return Policy

Warranties can be a game-changer, so I made it a point to check:

  • Warranty: I looked for tailgates that came with a warranty for peace of mind.
  • Return Policy: I found that having a flexible return policy was crucial in case the tailgate didn’t fit or meet my expectations.

Final Thoughts

By the end of my research, I felt much more confident in my ability to choose the right replacement tailgate for my Ford F250. Whether I went for OEM or aftermarket, ensuring compatibility and durability was key. I hope my experiences and insights help you make an informed decision when it comes time to replace your tailgate!

Author Profile

Avatar
Sherry Burrell
I’m Sherry Burrell, the founder of Monkeyshine SB and a longtime believer in the joy that food can bring to a community. Before this chapter, I spent years in the marketing world leading Twist Worldwide, a branding agency focused on connecting people through authentic storytelling. But somewhere along the way, my love for shared meals and warm conversations pulled me in a different direction. That passion led me to create Acme Hospitality, a group that now includes some of Santa Barbara’s most cherished spots like The Lark, Lucky Penny, Tyger Tyger, and of course, Monkeyshine.

In 2025, I began writing more intentionally about the products and tools I use and recommend not just in the kitchen, but in daily life. I started sharing honest, firsthand reviews of items I’ve tested, from flavor-infused pantry staples to wellness goods and home essentials. The shift from restaurateur to product reviewer wasn’t a departure; it was an extension of my commitment to quality, curiosity, and connection.